In the backdrop of the brutal
consequences of eight people of
the Uraina tribe
Author: Habib Ibny Sanowar
The answer to the complaint
related to Rasulullah (pbuh)
is about morality:-
Atheists and non-Muslims
allegation of Prophet Mohammad
(peace be upon him), murder was
done in exchange of murder,
But why so brutally?
Is violent vengeance characters
more violent than justice but
dominated this incident?
In various Hadith books including
Sahih Bukhari, there is an
incident that 8 people from
Uraina tribe (according to some
description of Ukl tribe or both
tribes) converted to Islam, but
they became sick because the
weather in Medina was not
favorable for them. Rasulullah
(Sallallallahu Alaihi Wa Sallam)
sends them to a place outside
Madina and (as a medical) the
Sadakar there asked them to
drink camel milk and urine. They
go there and drink camel's milk
and urine, they get cured and
they become fat. Then they
abandoned Islam and killed the
shepherd of camels appointed by
Rasulullah (Sallallallahu Alaihi Wa
Sallam) and ran away with the
camels. After getting the news,
Rasulullah (Sallallallahu Alaihi Wa
Sallam) sent an army and caught
them and punished them.
[So Prophet muhammad Just
Order them to drink camel's urine
as treatment, not for all
muslims.]
The punishment that came to
them in the Hadith is:
1. Their hands and legs are cut
off.
2. Their eyes are given or
removed when they are given
with heated iron.
3. They were thirsty and asked
for water, but they were not
given water.
4. They are left in a stoney place
called 'Al-Harra' till death.
Here comes a complaint, murder
was not committed in exchange
of murder, but why so brutally?
Is violent vengeance characters
more violent than justice but
dominated this incident? Now
let's see, what did the people of
Uraina tribe do?
One. From the Hadith:
Anas (R. Narrated by), Rasulullah
(Sallallallahu Alaihi Wa Sallam)
lifted their eyes because they
too uprooted the eyes of the
shepherd.
[Source: Muslim Book:
16, Chapter: 2, Number: 4137]
Two. From the history book:
They (narrators) said: A group of
8 people from Urainah came to
the Prophet (Sallallallahu Alaihi
Wa Sallam) and accepted Islam,
but the weather in Medina was
not favorable for them. As a
result, Rasulullah (Sallallahu
Alaihi Wa Sallam) ordered them to
dwell near His milky camels that
were 6 miles from Medina to a
place called ' Zul Jadr ' adjacent to
' Quba ' near ' Ir '. They stayed
there until they got fat after
recovering. One morning they
attacked a herd of camels and
chased them away. The shepherd
of Rasulullah (Sallallallahu Alaihi
Wa Sallam) chased them with a
group of Yasar. He fought them
out. They cut off his [shepherd's]
hands and legs and scrubbed his
tongue and eyes with thorns,
causing him to die.
[Source: Ibn
Sa'd's ' Book at Tabakbat Al-Kabir
', 2 b :, P: 114, (English
Translation-S. Moinul Haq)]
Lest we forget the
ungratefulness, ungratefulness,
treason, treason, treason,
treason, robbery of the Uraina
tribe.
But the words that cannot
be forgotten, are -
1. They cut the hands and legs of
the shepherd.
2. They killed the shepherd's
tongue and eyes with thorns.
When that shepherd was dying
with
3. wounded tongues, he
was thirsty.
Why should the people of Uraina
be given water when they are
thirsty? While they brutally
scratched the shepherd's
tongue, they are lucky that their
tongues were not wounded the
same way.
They have suffered the same
consequences as they killed the
shepherd with brutal, cruel,
brutally torturing.
Rasulullah (Sallallahu Alaihi Wa
Sallam) can be kind as a human
being, Rahmatallil Alamin(blessing
for all creation) , He can
forgive the one who attempts his
own murder, He can leave him if
someone mixes him with his
food, show mercy to the one
who lifts a sword over his head
while sleeping; but He has no
right, cannot have any right to
show compassion, sympathy to
the brutal, brutal, brutal murder
organizers sitting in the judge's
seat.
Those who have a habit of
crying, let them keep doing it...